FEATURE:
Deep Breathing
IN THIS PHOTO: Kate Bush in 1989/PHOTO CREDIT: John Carder Bush
How No Kate Bush Albums Endures Because of One Song, and Why New Fans Need to Explore Her Work More Deeply
_________
LAST month…
IN THIS PHOTO: Kate Bush alongside Lindsay Kemp in the short film, The Line, the Cross and the Curve (1993)/PHOTO CREDIT: Guido Harari
I was a bit annoyed when reading a feature ranking Kate Bush’s songs. I have said how much I love what Spectrum Culture are doing. They are ranking her songs and writing a lot about each. However, I took issue with this part, and specifically what they wrote about The Saxophone Song. That is a track from 1978’s The Kick Inside. Kate Bush’s debut album. Apart from ranking it scandalously low at 106, they also said this: “James and the Cold Gun” appeared on The Kick Inside, the debut record on which the singer-songwriter was evidently finding her feet. The longevity of the album may well depend on THAT Emily Brontë tune. Bush, guided by her influences, was beginning to discover an individual voice in the chasm of British pop. “James and the Cold Gun” does not shy away from Bowie’s shadow, but it still proves a fairly rewarding listen on its own terms. – Eoghan Lyng”. A couple of points with what Lyng said about The Saxophone Song and The Kick Inside. I will broaden this out. That idea that Bush was “evidentially finding her feet” on The Kick Inside. There is no evidence to suggest that. Like she was stumbling and patchy. Instead, she was hugely confident and she found her voice right at the start. The Saxophone Song is a brilliant cut that would be heralded today if a modern artist recorded it. This idea that Kate Bush only got good after a few albums. Her debut seen by some as inessential and a little weak. What annoyed me is that idea that The Kick Inside only endures because of Wuthering Heights! Not to mention The Man with the Child in His Eyes, Moving, The Kick Inside, and Kite. There are gems-aplenty on The Kick Inside! This insane notion that there is only one brilliant song on that album. That people discuss and love it because of Wuthering Heights. Very few albums endure decades later because of one standout song. The Kick Inside is loved because it is a brilliant album with a lot of great songs.
That is one person’s opinion about The Kick Inside. Though it applies to all her albums. No Kate Bush album endures and survives as it has one great song. A couple of her albums are not so widely loved. Lionheart arrived in 1978, nine months after The Kick Inside. Even so, it has a few real treas. Wow, Kashka from Baghdad and Symphony in Blue. Hounds of Love certainly does not endure solely because of Runing Up That Hill (A Deal with God), so it seems insulting that her unique and hugely impressive debut gets acclaim and fandom now because of Wuthering Heights. Patently ridiculous! Look at any of her albums, and they all have a series of brilliant song. None of Bush’s albums dependant on one track alone. The Sensual World has The Fog, The Sensual World and This Woman’s Work. Never for Ever has Babooshka, Army Dreamers, Breathing, and The Wedding List. The Red Shoes has Moments of Pleasure, The Red Shoes, Rubberband Girl, and Lily. Aerial has Mrs. Bartolozzi, Nocturn and, well, you get my point! I do think that the Spectrum Culture feature is not a one-off. As I have said, I do love what they are doing and opinions are subjective. But this notion that one of the greatest debut albums of the 1970s remains fascinating, or barely loved today, is because of Wuthering Heights. It did bother me a lot. Nobody who is discovering Kate Bush’s albums is skipping all the tracks for that one golden one. Well, I hope not! Bushy is such a respected and influential artist because of her consistency. That all her albums, whilst not all universally loved, do have more than one remarkable song. Some artists write albums with singles in mind. They have one commercially huge song and struggle elsewhere. I don’t think Kate Bush ever thought like that. She is and always has been an albums artist, so she ensures that there is this consistency and evenness. She did not write Wuthering Heights knowing it to be a work of genius and then spend little time with the rest. She cared about everything and was committed to making an album strong. It is strong and, as highlighted, there are several brilliant tracks. All of this contributes to its modern legacy and importance.
In fact, are there are any other major artists where an album depends entirely on the grandeur or brilliance of one song? I think about works by David Bowie, Madonna, The Rolling Stones or whoever, and their classic albums are not beholden to one song. In fact, even many of their less essential records have a few terrific songs. It is dismissive and insulting for anyone to say that The Kick Inside rests everything on Wuthering Heights. It’s another reason why, when the album turns fifty in 2028, I am going to write as much as I can. Get people together to celebrate an album that has this incredible endurance. Because of everything on it, and not just her debut single! But that goes for all Kate Bush albums. If many do not admire The Red Shoes, the fact that it gets written about or people even mention it today goes beyond one track. I think all of her albums, perhaps except Director’s Cut (2011) endure now because of how different they all are. Each has a few diamond songs. All of them compelling in their own way. Some may not bur as bright and have as wide a fanbase as others, but they all have endured, because we discuss them and Kate Bush. It makes me wonder two things. When you get articles like the one early where it is short-sighted or uninformed about a Kate Bush album, is there this feeling that people are not listening to the album? Surely anyone listening to The Kick Inside in full appreciates how there are so many songs that contribute to its strength. It is not one amazing song and the rest are average. Streaming figures suggest that many might go for the obvious songs and do not really have great knowledge of entire albums. Unless you are an established fan, will you spend time with a Kate Bush album, and therefore get a greater appreciation of each track and how they go together so well? People like me who have been fans for decades know and love the albums. We understand why they are important today. Yet there are generations who may even only know about Hounds of Love as Stranger Things used Running Up That Hill (A Deal with God) in 2022. Do people think that Hounds of Love is such a respect album because of one song? You would hope not. It does implore me to keep writing about Kate Bush, as there is some truth in many skirting her albums to go for obvious songs. If deeper cuts are not played on the radio and people do not write about the albums, in a digital age where many handpick tracks and skim through albums, does this somewhat distort or weaken Bush’s obvious greatness to young listener who have a narrower or less informed views of the whole picture? The fact that C.D. and vinyl sales are rising means that younger people are buying albumns.
I feel a lot of this might be new music and not necessarily classic and older albums. Maybe I am wrong. It did get to me how, granted people are entitled to their opinion, that a debut as seismic as The Kick Inside is only worthy because of its sixth track. I explore all of her albums and there is not one where I am only waiting for one track. Knowing that the reason I respect Kate Bush s much is because of the consistency of her albums. Indeed, if any of her albums were seen as credible today because of one song, we would not be discussing her in such esteemed tones. It does make me curious how her albums are being digested today. Whether people spend enough time with them. As it is almost Christmas, anyone new to Kate Bush really does need to invest in her albums. Start out by buying one and then listen to it in full. It is tempting to stream everything and listen that way. Though committing to buying an album makes you listen in full. Only then can you appreciate the true depth of that album. That’s what I reckon. No artist like Kate Bush could endure and have such a legacy today if many of their albums had only one exceptional song. And as The Kick Inside is one of her best, I think we are safe to assume that Wuthering Heights is one of many great tracks. And that Never for Ever boasts several smashers. Even an album that requires patience and demands your full investment like 50 Words for Snow (2011) has quite a few astonishing tracks. Nobody listening to it and thinking that there is one song that is brilliant and the rest are forgettable. And I think this album will be seen in years to come as one of her best and most important – even if some critics now feel it is below par. I will always fight to show why Kate Bush is one of the greatest artists ever. How all of her albums, in their own way, warrant huge love. Her debut is a masterpiece. As is, say The Dreaming. These albums will be talked about decades from now because there is so much to love and explore. A debut album does not sell over a million copies because one of the singles is extraordinary and the other tracks are not worth much. Similarly, all the commercial success and affection future albums received is because of the whole. Even the imperfect moments added something. It made the album somehow more interesting and intriguing. So we do need to show her more respect and give time to listen to her albums in full. Only then can we appreciate all of the song and get a clearer and bolder impression. Cherry-picking songs or listening to the albums in chunks is a hollower and less satisfying experience. If you are one of those people who only knows Hounds of Love or Aerial because of one song, then go and change that. This Christmas, make sure that you listen to Kate Bush’s albums…
IN their full glory.
