FEATURE:
Can’t Buy a Thrill
PHOTO CREDIT: Alex Green/Pexels
Is There Room for Nuance and Discussion in Songs Around Some Tough and Controversial Themes?
__________
I have written features…
PHOTO CREDIT: Alexandre P. Junior/Pexels
before around a dream or hypothetical album. I am not a musician myself, so I could not compose songs. Though I have titles and ideas for lyrics. A cover for an album called, American Grammar, and a composition on the cover that depicts various controversies and scenarios. Including women’s reproductive rights being removed in the U.S. Looking around music, there are artists who are tackling bigger themes. Hip-Hop used to be the scene where big issues in society are tackled and discussed. Pop artists might occasionally discuss something away from the normal themes, though there has been a real absence of anything approaching political, socially-minded or controversial. A few songs here and there but, as there are so many big issues that can be discussed in music, I wonder whether artists feel nervous of blowback or dividing fans. When I mooted the possibility of an album, I mentioned Donald Fagen as a songwriting inspiration. What he has done in his solo album and being part of Steely Dan. He has addressed subjects that are quite tough or not discussed by other artists. He has not released an album for a while, and I look around if bigger subjects can be represented with some humour but also nuance and urgency. What is off limits and what is okay to put into song? When I was putting tracks together and themes in each, they did include sexual assault and misogyny, the climate emergency, and an ageing hipster that might be out of touch and struggles to keep up with modern music. Few artists are tackling a (pun not intended) burning issue. The climate emergency and how it is out biggest threat. Not to say the song would be humours, though you can write about it on an album and get a serious message across, but do so with a slightly lighter heart. Giving it layers and nuance. There have been songs in the past, mainly be female artists, about weight loss drugs such as Ozempic. It is not deigned to be a weight loss drug. It is designed treat adults with type 2 diabetes by helping manage blood sugar levels and lower cardiovascular risks. However, it has sort of been repurposed by many celebrities.
At the moment, there are a few celebrities who have been highlighted on social media and the press because of their dramatic weight loss. Ariana Grande was subjected to so much scrutiny. Whilst many were concerned and felt they needed to speak out, there was a lot of judgement and pressure on her. Though she is a role model, so it does need to be brought up, though in a more sensitive and respectful way. The same with actress Jenna Ortega. I suggested a song called Can’t Buy a Thrill (the title of Steely Dan’s 1973 debut album) could look at American culture and mention drugs like Ozempic and this horrifying thing of celebrities using it to lose weight. Can a subject like this ever be brought into music? If done with intelligence, seriousness but also some wit, would the risk of criticism be there? The same with some universal like the climate emergency. So few artists documenting this in music. Reproductive rights, misogyny, racism, the endless horrors of Donald Trump, evil billionaires and A.I. I think all of these can and should be brought into music, though getting the tone right is difficult. Why are relatively few artists using their platform to go beyond their own lives? It is important they are open. Subjects like depression and loss are themes that definitely need to be in music. Though there is so much that should be tackled in music. Genocide in Gaza. It may seem a weighty album and quite bleak, though some of these topics – not the genocide, of course! -, can be slightly lightened by humour. We do seem to have reached a point where there are a few artists speaking out against genocide, highlighting he climate emergency, and attacking corruption, sexism and injustice. It is wonderful to see, though little of this goes into the music. Not to say Donald Fagen and Steely Dan are the best examples of artists incorporating serious issues into the music and doing it in a humorous or lighter way. Yet there have been songs in their catalogues that have a darker side. Maybe not ones we could write today. I do worry about all the things that should be sung about in songs that isn’t – or is done so rarely. Rather than it being a lack of awareness or concern, is it anti-commercial or not personal enough? Will fans take offence or hit back? My pitch of an album would blend in some funnier and lighter songs with ones that definitely highlight some, very impotent themes. Right now, we are seeing the planet burn, the ethics of the press and academia brought into question, genocide and warfare rage, and women’s rights and safety threatened and not really a priority. Music should be a place where these subjects are spotlighted. This might change. I hope so. We need more artists to…
TAKE a stand.
