FEATURE:
The Third Arrangement
IN THIS PHOTO: Kate Bush photographed in 1993 whilst filming the short film, The Line, the Cross and the Curve/PHOTO CREDIT: Guido Harari
My Fascination Around a Kate Bush Book Idea I Cannot Shake Off
_________
I used the words ‘The Third Arrangement’…
IN THIS ARTWORK: Snake Mary, from Steely Dan’s Rose Darling/ART CREDIT: Joan LeMay (via Expanding Dan)
at the top, because it is similar to a Steely Dan song. That was The Second Arrangement. It was meant to feature on their 1980 album, Gaucho, but it got wiped. Donald Fagen and Walter Becker (mainly Fagen and producer Gary Katz, I think) tried to rebuild or re-record it but it was too much of an ask. The track actually appeared fairly recently and was saved from the ashes somehow. It is a great song, and it makes me think of the songs of the mighty Dan. I mention them because, as I have said before, I was hugely inspired by the book, Quantum Criminals: Ramblers, Wild Gamblers, and Other Sole Survivors from the Songs of Steely Dan. You can buy it here. The concept was sort of down to Joan LeMay. She is an artist who collaborated with author and journalist Alex Pappademas. In the book “Pappademas and artist Joan LeMay give a roadmap to the Steely Dan extended universe through the lens of the characters at the heart of the band's songs. Alongside Pappademas' explorations, LeMay's paintings render touching portraits of Steely Dan's influences and inheritors, and speculative illustrations of the personalities who populate its world. Their book uncovers the vast constellation of lyrical references, artistic influences and social and political contexts surrounding the band and its music”. You can read this interview between NPR and Joan LeMay from 2023 (the year the book was published). I posted on Instagram saying how much I love this book and want to do something similar with Kate Bush. Such a fresh and original way to approach an artist. Using their characters as guides and focal points, I cannot think of too many other examples of this.
That might be the first ‘issue’ attempting something the same with Kate Bush: it has already been done. I messaged Joan LeMay and she liked the idea of my approach but, as she came up with this incredible idea, I don’t think I could justify one for Kate Bush. Not exactly the same. I am getting future nostalgic. As I write this – 9th October, 2026 – we are in this moment when Kate Bush could announce a new album at any point. If it has been announced before I share this feature, I will have to hastily rewrite! Next year, we mark forty-five years of her fourth studio album, The Dreaming. In 2028, Wuthering Heights (her debut single) and The Kick Inside (her debut album) turn fifty. I have published a series on my blog, Kate Bush: Them Heavy People: The Extraordinary Characters in Her Songs. It is needed now, though I managed to feature dozens of characters from her albums, B-sides and beyond. The thought of bringing that idea into a glorious hardback is tantalising. Not to repeat myself too heavily. One of the best days I ever had in London was going to a little bar in Old Street – I forget what it was called -, where there was this launch/signing of the Steely Dan book. Joan LeMay lived in London at the time but has since moved back to her native U.S. She was there, a couple of piles of this book. I bought a good beer got a couple of signed copies, and sat outside the bar as Steely Dan songs were played. The experience of the nice weather, the beer, LeMay and The Dan coexisting in this brilliant cocktail as I opened the book and started to read. An experience I cannot replicate, it was memorable because the book is so beautifully written and illustrated. The artwork by LeMay is fabulous. All these Steely Dan characters who we only knew through the words of Fagen and Becker now brought to life. I shall get to Kate Bush soon. I think the world now needs a group like Steely Dan. Or a new Donald Fagen album (his most recent, Sunken Condos, was released in 2012). So many big topics that can be tackled through smart, witty but cutting lyrics.
Sexual abuse and the men who boast about it. Genocide and the ignorance around it. Sexism and inequality at music festivals. Attacks on trans people and the L.G.B.T.Q.I.A.+ community. The abortion ban in the U.S. and how women’s bodies and rights are policed and restricted. Political corruption and fascism in the U.S. and here. Lighter songs that deal with, among other things, living in overpriced flats and sharing with others; an older person adrift of new music and terms; an awkward flirtation and fantasy at a dive coffee bar. I came up with possible track lists: The New Jane Doe, Hipsterlooza, American Grammar, Long Shot, Negative Space, Can’t Buy a Thrill (which is the title of Steely Dan’s 1972 debut album), Katy’s Switch, Eastside, For Those in the Back Rows, I’ll Get to New York City One Day Soon. Record it out of New York’s Electric Lady Studios and have a singer, a cast of brilliant musicians and this wonderfully produced album. Go for an all-time great album cover. The album will be called American Grammar, and it would be a genuinely compelling and striking cover. It is a dream, of course – I cannot read or write music (only lyrics) and have neither the money or connections to make it happen -, but we are in a time when the pen of Becker and Fagen is needed more than ever. Hip-Hop, Pop and other genres really not stepping up when it comes to tackling hefty topics. That’s why re-reading Quantum Criminals: Ramblers, Wild Gamblers, and Other Sole Survivors from the Songs of Steely Dan was and is such a joy. If anything, there are more characters through Kate Bush’s work than Steely Dan’s. Not that Joan LeMay would illustrated a hypothetical Kate Bush book, but I love the thought of seeing Kate Bush’s characters similarly brought to (vivid) life. There are many advantages of a book. I have said how Kate Bush is arguably one of the most influential modern-day artists. In terms of her impact on some of the very best artists of today. Everyone from FKA twigs, Charli xcx, Chappell Roan, CMAT, Florence + The Machine and beyond.
We are coming up to Christmas. In terms of recommendations, Kate Bush fans new should definitely invest in a book or two about her. Maybe Graeme Thomson’s Under the Ivy: The Life and Music of Kate Bush (oft-quoted and sourced for my blog), or Tom Doyle’s Running Up That Hill: 50 Visions of Kate Bush. There is little exploration of Bush’s work now. I guess in 2028 there will be features and things published because of those anniversaries. When she announces a new album, there will be this explosion of new interest. However, I don’t think there any books announced or anything substantial. Which is a shame, as I feel Kate Bush’s influence and importance is potentially at its most widespread and white-hot right now. Aside from Spectrum Culture ranking her songs and exploring them in detail, there is scant deep diving. Aside from Spectrum Culture scandalously featuring so many songs from The Kick Inside in the low positions, it is a proper connection and investigation of Bush’s music. The more that these kind of features are shared, the more her entire discography is discovered. That is what books do for artists too: they bring in new discoverers and approach their music in a very interesting and detailed way. Aside from biographies and a few other books here and there, there has not been enough written about her. Nothing that spotlights and discusses all the brilliant and distinct characters. Who we use as a jump-off point to talk about different themes and aspects of Kate Bush and her life.
There are drawbacks for any book project. I have never written one and have no idea as to the realities of how long it will take. As it is, living in London, I am barely getting by with a full-time job. I would not realistically be able to write one around my job and have the focus and time to complete it quickly enough. I am a journalist and not necessarily the most arresting writer. A book might require something more dynamic and interesting. Alex Pappademas wrote with such intelligence, passion and originality when documenting Steely Dan’s cast of heroes, misfits and side players. Also, a new author would not get a deal or an advance. Most likely, I – or someone writing a book – would get a percentage of the profits. This is a book that might not garner enormous sales so, when all is said and done, walking away with a couple or few grand. Not that it is about the money, but few people have the luxury of taking a year off from a job and writing a book. And writing one around a job seems like an impossibility! When Kate Bush does release a new album (I am thinking next year), I know there will be some new characters to discuss. 2011’s 50 Words for Snow had a few. So it might be worth considering one after that album comes out. Perhaps next year will see some new Kate Bush books arrive. There is this gap in the market. I have talked about it before but, re-exploring Quantum Criminals: Ramblers, Wild Gamblers, and Other Sole Survivors from the Songs of Steely Dan has sparked something. I think the money and time issues are a big factor. Though the chance to have this book out in the world about Kate Bush is always at the back of my mind. I have also muses about writing a 33 1/3 book if the opportunity arose. About The Kick Inside. Leah Kardos wrote one in 2024 on Hounds of Love, though feel there is room for a second. I feel, at present, time commitments and financial sacrifices and pitfalls prohibit me from realistically writing a book. And how easy is it to pitch to a publish and get the idea accepted? Writing a book is so fulfilling and would be a dream come true. It might have to wait until I am in a more financially stable position. Joan LeMay’s brilliant character-led idea for Steely Dan resonated with me and has not escaped my mind. Not that I would replicate Quantum Criminals: Ramblers, Wild Gamblers, and Other Sole Survivors from the Songs of Steely Dan for my book, but take some of its elements (the character focus) and do something different. It might not be chronological and there would be unique aspects. Perhaps the idea will come to light…
ONE day.
