FEATURE:
Struggling Heights
IN THIS PHOTO: Kate Bush in 1981/PHOTO CREDIT: Clive Arrowsmith
Does Modern Pop’s Limits and Restrictions Mean We Will Never Hear Anyone As Diverse Yet Universally Loved as Kate Bush?
_________
PEOPLE might shoot straight back…
IN THIS PHOTO: Kate Bush on the German T.V. show, Rock Pop, on 13th September, 1980 performing Babooshka
at me with names of artists who are diverse and accomplished as Kate Bush. What worries me is, more and more, how it is harder for artists to take time between albums and craft something different yet highly accomplished. There are incredible greats like Charli xcx who are prolific and produce these amazing albums. What strikes me hardest about Kate Bush is how she has recorded these albums that do not repeat the last, yet are all extraordinary in their own way. Looking around modern music, I cannot readily think of many artists who are adored and highly influential who have recorded albums that chart wide-ranging sonic territories. Look at the waves of Pop artists emerging. I think there is still a need for them to be accessible and digestible. A reliance on music that can be shared on social media and make an impact instantly. This often means that music that is more explorative and uncommercial is pushed to the fringes. These artists are more interesting, though they are not exactly as celebrated and spotlighted as Pop artists making music that is more mainstream and similar. There is a lot of homogenisation in music. I grant there are some modern icons forming. Stunning artists who do evolve between albums. Though none quite like Kate Bush. Think about how The Kick Inside (her 1978 debut), The Sensual World (1989) and 50 Words for Snow (2011) are all vastly different. Her albums were released over a period of three decades and more, so we are talking about someone long-running. Yet, I struggle to think of a modern artist quite as diverse and innovative as Kate Bush. Are we to blame modern tastes and expectations? The dominance of streaming and trying to make music instantly memorable in a time when attention spans are short?
I do think people have an appreciate for music that is not poppy and same-sounding. Interesting artists who are making sounds that are unique and fascinating. But I do wonder whether they are going to be supported and spotlighted enough so that they are recording and releasing albums years from now. I feel there is an expectation for artists to releasee albums quite close together. That pressure to allows be making stuff and out there unless they are forgotten about. Kate Bush had a slightly luxury where she could take increasingly longer gaps between albums. Over fifteen years since her most recent album, 50 Words for Snow, we have no immediate expectation of a new album. I feel these gaps mean she can take time to push herself and go past the normal. An artist who has traversed so many distinct and diverse sounds, can modern artists achieve this with greater pressure on their shoulders? I have so much love for modern artists. Of course, that is not to say there are no artists who are as interesting as Kate Bush. A few have released a series of albums that cover a number of genres and canvases. But anyone I think of that I can compare to Kate Bush are artists from decades ago. Giant modern artists who are widely adored and acclaimed, I feel, could not be afforded the time and luxury of recording an album as genius and ambitious as Hounds of Love (1985), three years after releasing something as experimental and out-there as The Dreaming (1982). We could say because Kate Bush is unique that it would be unfair to compare any other artists to her. Discount them. My wider point is that there are these restrictions today on young artists. Maybe a lack of money or ability to gestate ideas and spend years between music does stunt some of their potential. Think about a double album like Aerial. Kate Bush’s 2005 masterpiece, it may be considered the type of album that falls outside of Pop. That maybe should be made by an older artist. Not trendy or the kind those on TikTok and Instagram would listen to.
This is the same woman who released Never for Ever, which I feel would very much be accessible to social media user now. Can you name many artists who have released a series of albums as broad as Kate Bush’s? Not many spring to mind. Money might be a reason. Bush could afford to build her own studio to a point, which meant she could afford to take time producing an album where she was not watching the clock and worrying about cost. She also has this curiosity for various genes, cultures and music that is a result of her generation, relatives and time she was young. Today, are young artists being exposed to classic albums and a selectin of music as variegated and wide as I was when I was young? Is the art of the album undervalued and important now? I feel one of the major reasons Bush is so influential and admired is because she could be a bit eccentric and experimental for one album and then a little bit more restrained and subtle for the next. The beauty and sensuality could sit with the wintery and expansive. One might also argue there are modern artists who have released a series of albums that are more consistent than Kate Bush’s work. Albums like Lionheart (1978), The Red Shoes (1993) and 50 Words for Snow (2011) not as respected as Hounds of Love or The Dreaming. But it is the fact that there are these instant masterpieces and more underappreciated gems that makes her discography so rewarding, rich and nuanced. You could say that Beyoncé is more consistent. She has released more masterpieces than Kate Bush, but I would argue that Beyoncé’s discography is not as eclectic and compelling as Kate Bush’s. Taylor Swift, Sabrina Carpneter and Charli xcx. All queens of the highest order, though their albums are less genre-hopping or varied as Kate Bush’s. Bush did not perform live music, so she could dedicate more time to writing and recording. Also, if a modern giant recorded something Pop-centric one moment and was critically acclaimed, could they follow up with something like The Sensual World or even The Dreaming and keep that momentum going? Do we expect them to release an album pretty similar to the last?
Something I have been thinking about. Whether we will see anyone as enduring and endlessly interesting as Kate Bush. That is not the fault of artists. Things have changed. I do feel that social media, streaming and the contemporary landscape and the pressure artists are under means we might not see anyone quite like Kate Bush. But is it possible to deliver albums as different as The Kick Inside and 50 Words for Snow without there being this giant gap? Those albums released over thirty years apart. That does raise other questions and considerations. The legacy Kate Bush has is immense. Her work affecting and impacting artists and people across multiple genre and sectors of society because each of her albums has its own skin and sound. You cannot compare them. She could be quite mad and boundary-pushing on one album. The next a bit more introspective or slow-burning. I am not sure whether many artists could take that risk. When I listen to contemporary innovators, they do switch things up between albums. But they are releasing them a year, two or three since the last, so it does mean that they have not had enough time to mature and experience life so that their next album is as big move forward. That need for fast turnaround. But you can be a modern genius and be widely admired if you have a natural genius that means, even if your albums are fairly similar, they are still important and affecting. I am thinking of a Taylor Swift, ROSALÍA or Bad Bunny.
This might be too complex or big a subject for me to do justice to. I was thinking about this when listening to The Red Shoes beside The Kick Inside. If a modern artist released albums like this, in terms of how worlds apart they are, I wonder if that would be a huge gamble commercially. I am not saying that a modern artist can never be as good as Kate Bush. That is not true. Though her albums all distinct and so compelling in their own ways. A body of work that I don’t think has been equalled when it comes to their breadth, width and depth of lyrical and sonic inspiration. Can we blame modern Pop and an industry that does not always allow artists longer pauses between albums and the opportunity to craft albums that are distinctly different? Do modern artists want to. Plenty of artists do release albums that are different to their previous ones, but I have yet to find too many that are in the same ballpark as Kate Bush. If Kate Bush continued to make albums like Hounds of Love after 1985, I don’t think she would be seen now as brilliant and progressive. She could release genius replicas. But it is the fact that her subsequent albums were not like that, faults and all, that makes her so much more brilliant and bold. She did not comprise or want to do the same thing, which could mean she risked alienating some fans and critics. Modern artists can take these leaps, but I feel there are too many risks and fears of losing traction and momentum. I might be wrong. It would be interesting to hear what people think on this and why, decades from now, the best of the current age will not leave behind a catalogue quite like Kate Bush’s. It is a shame in a way. I feel few artists will be as enduring, because their music does not quite have the same depths and layers as Bush’s. How we need to reappraise some of Bush’s work rather than see them all as faultless. If a modern artists puts out six or seven wonderful albums that are broadly similar, will that be as impactful decades from now as if they put out wildly different albums that take a bit of time to appreciate? It seems that, alas, there could or will never be another artist quite like…
THE sublime Kate Bush.
