FEATURE:
Say You Love Me
Fleetwood Mac at Fifty
__________
THIS is an album…
IN THIS PHOTO: Fleetwood Mac during a U.S. interview in 1975/PHOTO CREDIT: Polaris
that introduced Stevie Nicks and Lindsey Buckingham into Fleetwood Mac. The band’s eponymous album of 1975 was released on 11th July. I wanted to mark fifty years of a classic. The band getting these new members and losing Bob Welch (who departed in 1974). I am going to come to a review of the amazing Fleetwood Mac. You will recognise songs from it such as Rhiannon, Landslide and Say You Love Me. Though not as known and acclaimed Rumours (1977), Fleetwood Mac was a hugely important album. One that saw this new dynamic in the band. A number one in the U.S. upon its release, there are a few reasons to celebrate Fleetwood Mac. Apart from the fact it turns fifty on 11th July. There is a lot of focus on the band. There has been this continued popularity. The Guardian recently wrote how the band are ubiquitous. Rumours continues to top lists of the best-selling vinyl albums of the year. One that continues to reach new listeners. They also mention how a theatrical phenomenon focuses on a band and story that draws comparisons with Fleetwood Mac:
“The Broadway hit Stereophonic, written by David Adjmi, opened in the West End this week after becoming the most nominated play in Tony award history (it ended up winning five out of 13, including best play). It invites theatregoers to journey back to 1976 and “plug into the electric atmosphere as one up-and-coming rock band record the album that could propel them to superstardom. Amid a powder keg of drugs, booze and jealousy, songs come together and relationships fall apart.”
If that sounds remarkably similar to the story of how Fleetwood Mac recorded Rumours, then that’s exactly what the album’s producer Ken Caillat thought: he sued the producers for the play’s similarity to his memoir, settling out of court earlier this year, though Adjmi has always denied his play is purely about Fleetwood Mac, regardless of the many parallels.
But Stereophonic is just the tip of the Mac iceberg that has come into view in recent years. Novel readers and TV viewers have enjoyed Daisy Jones and the Six, which also used the Fleetwood Mac template as the basis for its story. Their smooth, adult-oriented rock sound also permeated music throughout the last decade, present in records by artists such as Sharon Van Etten, Julien Baker, the Weather Station and more. If you want a dancier version of the band, you can go to the club night Fleetmac Wood, playing beefed-up remixes.
And Mac themselves are as popular as ever: in last week’s album chart, the compilation 50 Years – Don’t Stop sat at No 6 (after 340 weeks on the chart), while Rumours is at No 22 (after 1098 weeks on the chart). Nearly half a century on from Rumours’ release, Fleetwood Mac are still very big business.
Partly that’s down to the continued resonance of the story of the album: two couples tearing themselves apart and committing their feelings to tape. (It is perhaps not a coincidence that Abba, another 70s band whose troubled relationships were set to lush pop, are also undimmingly popular.) But it’s also down to the music: Rumours still sounds like a treat when you play it”.
In 2015, marking forty years of Fleetwood Mac, Ultimate Classic Rock explored and discussed the background of the album. I would advise people to read the entire article. Even though the music on the 1975 album – and its follow-up, Rumours – is phenomenal, personal relationships within the ranks were falling apart:
“While the new Fleetwood Mac clicked as a musical unit, the personal relationships between various members of the band were falling apart — Christine and John McVie's marriage was nearing its end, and Buckingham and Nicks were close to breaking up before they joined the lineup. Over time, both couples' demise would form a key component of the group's legacy (and help inspire their best-selling album), but in the short term, that air of uncertainty fueled a number of future classics.
One example is the Nicks composition "Landslide," which, as she explained to Performing Songwriter, she wrote during a trip to Colorado when Buckingham was rehearsing for a possible project with Don Everly.
"This is right after the Buckingham Nicks record had been dropped. And it was horrifying to Lindsey and I," she laughed, "because we had a taste of the big time, we recorded in a big studio, we met famous people, we made what we consider to be a brilliant record and nobody liked it [...] I had gotten to a point where it was like, 'I’m not happy. I am tired. But I don’t know if we can do any better than this. If nobody likes this, then what are we going to do?' So during that two months I made a decision to continue. 'Landslide' was the decision."
Nicks also contributed "Rhiannon," which she wrote shortly before joining Fleetwood Mac after reading Mary Leader's novel Triad. The book's story incorporates elements of the Welsh legend of Rhiannon, which Nicks unwittingly wove into the song even though, by her own admission, she didn't really know about it until much later.
"I didn’t know anything about Rhiannon when I wrote the song 'Rhiannon,'" explained Nicks. "I was just reading a paperback book, and the name Rhiannon came up and I loved it."
Telling Buckingham and engineer Richard Dashut that she wanted them to go outside and record birds singing for a demo she was working on, she recalled: "Of course Richard and Lindsey looked at me like, ‘She’s really gone around the twist this time, huh?’ And I said, ‘Don’t you think that Rhiannon is a beautiful name?’ Lindsey said, ‘Yeah, it is a beautiful name.’ Three months later, we joined the band and I played it on the piano in my little simple way of playing ... they loved it."
That sort of creative serendipity seemed to surround the sessions for the new album, which wrapped in the spring of 1975. Simply titled Fleetwood Mac to reflect the reinvigorated band's renewed sense of purpose, it arrived in stores July 11, 1975. Sales started slowly, and never really took off in the group's native U.K., but they toured behind it with a young band's dogged enthusiasm. "There were no limousines and Christine slept on top of the amps in the back of the truck," Nicks told Uncut. "We just played everywhere and we sold that record. We kicked that album in the ass."
That effort eventually paid off in spades. Fleetwood Mac's first single, the Christine McVie number "Warm Ways," failed to chart, but the follow-up — "Over My Head," also courtesy of McVie — peaked at No. 20 in the States, paving the way for the huge hits "Rhiannon" and "Say You Love Me" (both No. 11). In September 1976, over a year after its release, Fleetwood Mac topped the album charts, selling more than five million copies along the way.
For the group's longtime rhythm section, Fleetwood Mac's success was a sweet reward for years of grueling — and often futile-seeming — work. "John and I have been through some unbelievable moral/mental decisions," Fleetwood told Melody Maker. "But we never wanted to kick it. Perseverance and work kept Fleetwood Mac together and a lot of people before us gave up, sayin' 'This isn't worth it.'"
Christine McVie added: "We did interviews with Newsweek and People magazine recently. It's funny being on the same page next to a big article on Jimmy Carter. We're reaching audiences that never heard of Fleetwood Mac, and it's good to have finally gotten away from questions like, 'Whatever happened to Peter Green or Jeremy Spencer?'"
Of course, as Fleetwood conceded in his NME interview, that success came after another step away from the blues-influenced sound Fleetwood Mac started with. "We're certainly not sounding the same as we were eight years ago," he laughed, while hinting at the strong interpersonal dynamics that would come to shape — and occasionally overshadow — the band over the decades to follow”.
I am going to end with a review of Fleetwood Mac from Pitchfork. Fifty years after a new line-up of Fleetwood Mac came together and created the first of several classic albums, the music and sound is still hugely popular and influential. There are few albums of the 1970s as important as Fleetwood Mac. Anyone who knows the band for Rumours and has not explored beyond that need to go back to the band’s 1975 release:
“Fleetwood Mac existed for nearly a decade prior to the release of Fleetwood Mac in 1975 but not in a manner that modern audiences would recognize. The story of how Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks transformed the British blues band anchored by drummer Mick Fleetwood and bassist John McVie is well and often told in countless documentaries, retrospectives, and such reissues as this new triple-CD/single-DVD Super Deluxe Edition. Repetition has curdled this fascinating tale, rendering happy accidents as the work of divine providence, but by adding a disc of rough alternate takes along with a disc of live material, this Super Deluxe Edition helps make the familiar seem fresh once again.
Tired though it may be, the prehistory of Fleetwood Mac is essential to understanding the album because the record exists at the intersection of two very different rock’n’roll aesthetics. By the time 1975 rolled around, the Mac were survivors. Mick and John—the two constants in the band since its inception through today—had the luck to work with two troubled guitar geniuses. Peter Green dominated the group’s earliest and bluesiest records, eventually succumbing to LSD right around the time his cohort Jeremy Spencer abandoned music for a religious cult. Neither departure was clean, but guitarist Danny Kirwan acted as a bonding agent for the band until they found Bob Welch, a rocker with a sentimental streak who seemed content to linger in the amorphous space separating AOR rock and adult contemporary pop. If all this turnover wasn’t confusing enough, the band had to combat an imposter Fleetwood Mac assembled by their former manager.
All these names have wound up as footnotes to Fleetwood Mac history because Mick Fleetwood happened to fall for a demo from the unknown SoCal singer/songwriters Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks. If producer Keith Olsen, who helmed Buckingham Nicks’ self-titled 1973 album, never played Mick that tape, odds are good Fleetwood Mac would’ve wound up hiring some other hotshot blues guitarist. Instead, Fleetwood wound up finding something he’d later call “IT” within Buckingham Nicks, a folk-rock duo whose music shared almost no similarities to the albums Fleetwood Mac made prior to 1975. The one possible musical connection between the two groups was the melodicism of Christine McVie, a singer-songwriter who played piano with the blues combo Chicken Shack prior to her marriage to John. Once they were bride and groom, Christine officially joined the band in 1971, contributing appealingly soft and hooky counterpoints to the spacey rock of Kirwan and Welch.
Nevertheless, there was no clear analog in the Fleetwood Mac discography to the dreamy folk of Nicks and the barbed pop perfectionism of Buckingham, sounds that were as distinctly American as Fleetwood Mac’s blues jams were British. Buckingham Nicks were also survivors of languishing in musical limbo the West Coast, but were not quite naive upstarts when they accepted Fleetwood’s offer to join Fleetwood Mac: they had been playing the same game for just as long as the Mac, only in a different league. That’s why the 1975 album called Fleetwood Mac—the group’s second album to be named after the band; according to David Wild’s liner notes in the 2018 Super Deluxe Edition, fans apparently distinguish it from its predecessor by calling it “the White Album” but it’s hard to imagine there are many listeners who bother with such a distinction—feels like a debut: the unexpected intersection of two parallel spheres offers something genuinely new.
Listening to Fleetwood Mac now, decades after it turned the group into superstars, it still seems fresh, unlike any other of its 1975 peers, and that’s all due to how the band merged two aesthetics. Fleetwood Mac, especially in the years following Peter Green’s departure, were something of a mood band, achieving a hazy, spacious vibe that lacked definition. Buckingham Nicks were their counterparts, focused not just on the precision of songs but also productions: their 1973 album captures nascent versions of the two singer/songwriters, where Nicks’ delicateness is balanced by Buckingham’s manic perfectionism.
Buckingham did attempt to get Fleetwood Mac to march to his beat—legend has it he was attempting to tell John how to play a part until the bassist put the hammer down, telling Buckingham that the band was named after him—but wound up settling for compromise, assisting Nicks and Christine in deepening their compositions, while his band gave soul and elasticity to his tightly wound songs. Such synthesis is the appeal of Fleetwood Mac, in part because it’s assembled from so many lingering ideals from the ’60s: hippie mysticism, pop practicalism, R&B grooves, and rock rebellion all molded into music that is simultaneously professional, personal, commercial, and eccentric.
By piling on alternate takes, single edits, and live material, the Super Deluxe Edition underscores how Fleetwood Mac worked at achieving this fusion. Maybe the early versions are rough, but they feel kinetic because the band is figuring out just who they were. Even better is the live material, where the band navigates the distance between their early blues roots and newly discovered immaculate pop. Because he plays lead guitar and sings, Buckingham winds up dominating, but the wonderful thing about these versions of “Oh Well” and “The Green Manalishi (With the Two Pronged Crown)” is that they’re blues tunes fronted by a musician whose instincts pushes him in the opposite direction of the blues, which gives these performances a thrilling energy.
Even if the bonus material is worthwhile, the music that remains marvelous is the proper album. Perhaps its origins are in leftovers—many of the songs were originally intended for a planned second Buckingham Nicks album, “Crystal” is revived from the first, the brilliant power pop of “Blue Letter” is taken from the unheralded Curtis Brothers—but the Fleetwood Mac feels unified because this album is an album of convergence. Every element of the album teems with boundless possibilities, so much of which could be found in the absolutely bewitching Nicks-helmed “Rhiannon,” which is why Fleetwood Mac seems thrillingly alive and resonant longer after it has been absorbed into our collective consciousness”.
I am not sure whether there will be a lot of new features about Fleetwood Mac ahead of its fiftieth anniversary on 11th July. I hope there is. As I write this (11th June), we are a month out. It is an album that I first heard as a child and I have loved it ever since. So exciting to hear Lindsey Buckingham and Stevie Nicks in Fleetwood Mac. Many existing fans of the band might have been unsure in 1975. However, it is clear that the change was a positive thing. They added something incredible to the band! The phenomenal Fleetwood Mac still moves the senses…
FIFTY years later.