FEATURE:
expectations
PHOTO CREDIT: Ryan McGinley for DAZED
Does Olivia Rodrigo’s you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love Stand Among the Best Albums of the Century?
__________
WE are…
twenty-six years into this century. In terms of the best albums of the century, thee are sites who have selected their choices. Rolling Stone chose their best albums of the century last year. 250 in their feature. The Guardian produced their list in 2019. Paste published a list last year. There are some differences between them and, of course, it is subjective. However, I do think that there are some repeats. Those albums that are definitely the greatest of this century. In my list, Fiona Apple’s Fetch the Bolt Cutters will be up there with Beyoncé’s Lemonade. Perhaps Radiohead would be in there too. There has been a lot of competition the past decade. So many tremendous albums released. Not only is Olivia Rodrigo’s you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love the best album of this year. It is also strong enough to compete for the best album of this century. I shall come to some reviews of the astonishing third album from the California-born artist. I don’t think that it would be an exaggeration to say that you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love could sit alongside the very best of this century. A work that not only has stunned and blown people away now. It will endure for years to come. You do wonder just how far Olivia Rodrigo can go. All three of her studio albums have been enormously acclaimed. There is something about you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love that surpasses 2021’s SOUR and 2023’s GUTS. Those two albums are tremendous. Not only is you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love the sound of an artist at the top of her game and at her most confident. In terms of its sheer quality, Olivia Rodrigo’s third studio album is absolutely among the best albums we have heard this century. Some will argue against my assertion. Critical reaction to you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love has been phenomenal. The test of time will be if people are talking about the album years from now. I do think that we are going to be heralding the album as a masterpiece in years to come.
I want to move to a recent interview with Olivia Rodrigo. This is an artist who is highly beloved. Very grounded and an idol for so many people, there is so much rightful admiration for this incredible artist. DAZED chatted with Olivia Rodrigo. They say how she “embraces her ‘big girl’ era on her new record, an exuberant account of the promise and pitfalls of falling in love”:
“Olivia Rodrigo is growing up. While she’s still the same young woman with big feelings and a penchant for babydoll dresses, the 23-year-old appears much more self-assured than the anxious adolescent of SOUR and GUTS when we meet to discuss her new album, you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love. (Ironically, she seems happier too.) She’s speaking to me from her native Los Angeles, her cherubic face beaming as she tells me about her morning: mainly interviews and signing vinyls ahead of the much-anticipated release. The record is about her first “adult relationship” – likely her romance with English actor Louis Partridge, rumoured to have ended in late 2025. She tells me she finished making the record in March. “I’m still so close to it,” she says, adding that she’s ready to put it out into the world now. “I’m excited for it to not be ‘mine’ any more.”
Are there any new experiences you’ve had since GUTS that you’ve written about on you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love?
Olivia Rodrigo: This album is about my first time being in an adult relationship; it’s me discovering what romantic love looks like in real time. I’ve been in relationships before that were really exciting and tumultuous in a teenage way, but this was my first time being in a real, “big girl” relationship. And when you’re in an intimate relationship, it holds up a mirror and shows you parts of yourself that you would never normally see. That was an endless source of inspiration – something that I’m still mining.
Was it challenging to write about love from a more joyful place?
Olivia Rodrigo: For sure. That was the initial challenge of the album. Fiona Apple once said, ‘When I’m happy, why would I want to stop what I’m doing and sit down at the piano?’ which I think is funny and very true. But all of the best love songs or poems have an element of sadness or longing or fear in them. There’s even an element of anxiety in “drop dead” – like, ‘Oh God, I hope this person likes me.’ Even in our most joyous moments, there’s always this thought in the back of your head: ‘Is this gonna last forever?’ That’s the dichotomy of life. The scale is always balancing itself out.
You seem pretty well-adjusted for a girl so famous. What do you do to stay grounded?
Olivia Rodrigo: The people you hang around with are important. My friends are really honest with me sometimes – they’ll just be like, ‘No, that’s not good, don’t do that.’ And I have really awesome parents, too. I think I lucked out on the parent lottery. They have always been a really safe, stable resource for me. I also just really love what I do. I think that, as long as it comes from a place of passion and excitement and not from a place of ‘I need to do this so people like me’, that’s the recipe for success and happiness. I try to remember that that’s what it’s really all about”.
I do want to get to a few of the reviews for you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love. You can get some perspective as to why this album has made such a huge impact. Definitely the best album of 2026, it is also equal to the best of the century. Rolling Stone UK provided their take on the new Olivia Rodrigo album. We are seeing this icon in the making. People hate the ‘icon’ word, but in terms of artists who are going to endure for decades and are growing stronger with every album, Rodrigo is a modern-day great. She has released an album I feel will resonate for so long because people can identify with it. It will not age or seem like a product of its time. The songwriting so strong that it can challenge the strongest albums we have seen in the twenty-first century:
“Proust called love reciprocal torture, Bukowski said it was stranger than grass on fire, and Olivia Rodrigo admitted it was fucking embarrassing. Yet on ‘Drop Dead’, the opening cut from her new album, here she is in free fall, heart on her sleeve, ready to risk everything as hope and possibility flicker over a magical night — poets, philosophers, and past lessons be damned. The song is a pure dopamine rush, built on heart-thudding percussion and glowing synths, the thrill of romance and anticipation ramping up with each euphoric line: “Kiss me, and I might drop dead.”
This could well be the giddiest we’ve ever heard Rodrigo, who wasn’t afraid to pack her blockbuster albums Sour and Guts with punky, pissed-off energy and wildly relatable, angst-filled anthems. For her third release, it might have seemed like she was ready for a simpler, googly-eyed lover-girl era — except, come on, we all know she’s too witty, too self-aware, and just too talented a songwriter to go with rose-colored confessions about a new relationship.
The title was one clue: You Seem Pretty Sad for a Girl So in Love makes it clear that this project is a complex emotional ride, one that’ll turn platitudes and presumptions about love on their head. There were sonic Easter eggs dotting “Drop Dead,” which was also the first single, like a reference to the Cure’s “Just Like Heaven” and the hazy fuzz of guitars that she and longtime producer Dan Nigro went for, conjuring New Wave gods and the image of a lonely-hearted Robert Smith (more on him in a bit). All of it sets up something closer to real life as Rodrigo moves through the full arc of a relationship — the dreamy honeymoon phase, the first hints of conflict, the crushing goodbye — to achieve her most complete, musically adventurous album yet.
First, though, fireworks. The initial songs capture that feeling of falling in real time (Rodrigo has said the album is about her first “adult” relationship; many fans think she’s referring to actor Louis Partridge, whom she dated for more than a year). She’s still on a high on ‘Stupid Song’, a track that seems like a blissful ballad before saturated Eighties chords pipe in. ‘Honeybee’ is a sleepier cut that dips the energy that’s been rising, but it does serve as a tender moment that establishes the deep extent of her emotions. But then anxieties start build — and if there’s something Rodrigo does well, it’s dive into her insecurities with a mix of humour and honesty. There’s a mopey synth party on ‘Maggots 4 Brains’, a snapshot of the yearning and neediness that takes over when there’s distance from the person she loves: “Everything feels mouldy like the fruit that’s in my fridge / And everything that’s funny I wish I could tell to him.” The seams come apart a little more with each track, a testament to how perfectly she and Nigro sequenced the project, capturing the downward spiral of the relationship.
She’s blindly hopeful on ‘U + Me = <3’ and fully territorial on ‘My Way’. But the breaking point might be the stunning ‘Purple’, where she realises the love she’s found also means she’s losing herself. The balladry of ‘The Cure” and ‘Begged’ keep her turning the lens inward, though they threaten the momentum of the album. And if she needed to clarify her feelings more, help arrives on ‘What’s Wrong With Me’, when she’s joined by the Cure frontman himself. It’s a brilliant cameo; he’s been lurking everywhere on the album — nodded to constantly in the production and the lyrics — and finally he floats in, no longer an apparition but a guiding force. “I think you’re what’s wrong with me,” they sing in a line that suits both their discographies.
Rodrigo has always proudly displayed her references, drawing from Nineties rock and riot grrrl bands like Hole and Babes in Toyland on past collections, but here, she’s doing more than paying homage; she’s woven a sonic tapestry that any of her icons can fit into. Fans craving more aggressive, pop-punk energy might have trouble getting into the new sound at first, but Smith’s appearance is a testament to just how well it works. The electro-funhouse twitchiness of ‘Expectations’, which feels like it sprouted from a seed planted by the B-52s, adds another layer, keeping the listener on their toes.
A major strength of the album is how much Rodrigo’s storytelling has matured. For a girl who went stratospheric belting about teenage heartbreak on ‘Drivers License’ at 17, there’s new wisdom as she comes to the brutal realisation that you can adore someone more than anything and still have to let them go. She lands so many gutting lines: “If loving me means letting go and wishing me the best, then I guess I wish, I wish, I wish you loved me less,” she sings on ‘Less’. By the last track, ‘Cigarette Smoke’, she’s found a kind of peace — if not a full resolution quite yet — as she tries to move on. “The memories turn dark,” she repeats, over and over. Maybe they eventually fade, but the songs stay with you”.
Olivia Rodrigo is one of the defining voices of her generation. That is why you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love might have been such a hard album to realise. Expectations on her shoulders after two phenomenal albums. We are seeing a modern-day legend blossoming. No doubt you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love will be nominated for GRAMMYs. It is definitely going to top the albums of the year lists. It is far bigger and more glorious than that. An album that is as astonishing as some of the very best of this century. DIY delivered a five-star review of you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love. An album that ushers Olivia Rodrigo “ into her rightful position as one of her generation’s best artists”:
“Be it her response to inane internet discourse around her recent penchant for babydoll dresses (a homage to the juxtaposing cute-and-combat-boots look of ‘90s riot grrrl), or her unlikely friendship with Robert Smith (having brought him out onstage at both last year’s Glasto headline and last week’s Primavera ‘secret’ set), one thing is for sure - Olivia Rodrigo knows her references. But she also knows exactly who she is as an artist, too; that is, a supremely canny pop-rock songwriter who’s equally adept penning sad girl ballads as she is rageful, storming revenge bangers, expressing the emotional tumult of warts’n’all young womanhood with remarkable astuteness. Which makes it all the more exciting - indeed, is precisely why - that on third album ‘you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love’, she steps fully out of her former Disney star skin and into new territory so convincingly.
Thematically, admittedly, we’re hardly breaking new ground here - like predecessors ‘SOUR’ (2021) and ‘GUTS’ (2023), this latest record is still squarely centred around Olivia’s romantic encounters with the unfairer sex (namely, the world presumes, her ex-boyfriend, British actor Louis Partridge). Indeed, ‘yspsfagsil’ [catchy, we know - Ed] is made up exclusively of (anti)love songs, a 13-track narrative arc spanning the giddy beginnings of a burgeoning relationship to its bitter end. Opener ‘drop dead’ positively fizzes with the stomach-flipping thrill of early days butterflies; centrepiece ‘purple’, undercut by a skittish beat that bubbles like not-quite-boiling water, speaks of both kismet union and as-yet-unseen red flags (“Our paths intersect ‘til the two lines form a circle”; “It’s crazy, I had big dreams ‘til I tied myself to you”); and bruised break-up ballad ‘less’ lands like a modern Old Hollywood number to be played as the plane takes off from the Casablanca tarmac.
A tale as old as time, yes, but colouring in this story’s outline are referential, repertoire-widening brushstrokes that cast its painter in a whole new light. Showcasing Olivia’s knack for a swelling anthemic build (see also: ‘vampire’ and ‘traitor’), ‘stupid song’ then descends into a beat-driven bridge that begs to be screamed out loud, while ‘my way’ sees her kicking down jealousy’s door to claim possession of what’s hers via siren-esque squalls and gloriously bratty vocals that do their job of invoking queen of the babydoll, Kathleen Hanna, to make for one of the LP’s most thrilling moments. It’s a high point that is, perhaps, only surpassed by its should-be-closer ‘expectations’; the whiplash-inducing contrast between the closing bars of ‘less’ and this bolshy, Gary Numan-like paean to moving on is enough to elicit an audible whoop, while its smart structural echoes of ‘drop dead’ illustrate the benefit of hindsight better than words ever could. (Why the album doesn’t finish on this emphatic high, though, is a mystery).
Elsewhere, ‘maggots for brains’ moves the Paramore-esque pop-punk of ‘GUTS’ back a few decades, swapping anthemic chorus chants for for drum-pad stabs and twangy new wave guitars - a decidedly ‘80s palette that’s carried into ‘u + me = <3’ to imbue the doe-eyed ditty with the same jangly propulsion and youthful optimism of ‘Friday I’m In Love’. Because, of course, ‘yspsfagsil’ doesn’t just invoke the goth-rock legends in guitar tone, track title (‘the cure’), or lyric (‘drop dead’ namechecks ‘Just Like Heaven’); no, here, Olivia cements her reverence - and gives credence to it all - by having Robert Smith as her first ever on-record feature, on their spine-tingling duet ‘what’s wrong with me’.
Just as The Cure have become renowned as masters of emotional depth, marrying introspective poetry with earworm melody to create evergreen songs far greater than the sum of their parts, so Olivia Rodrigo has managed to mine the complicated, confusing, messy business of falling in and out of love to create an accessible yet hugely intelligent album that ushers her into her rightful position as one of her generation’s best artists”.
Go and get this album on vinyl. The divine and astonishing you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love is a modern masterpiece. No matter which albums you feel are the best of this century, I feel you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love can challenge them. There has been immediate impact and adulation. I don’t think it will end there. We will see you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love endure and picked up by a new generation years from now. Nobody knows what her next album will be, though you feel Olivia Rodrigo will top you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love. Signs that she is…
A world-class talent.
